Discussion:
Aruba recommendations
(too old to reply)
Jason
2003-08-15 12:38:18 UTC
Permalink
I'm off to Aruba soon and looking around the web, there seems to be a
choice of:

Mermaid Sport Divers
Dive Aruba
Pelican Watersports
Red Sails

Anyone got any personal experience of them? Mermaid seem to be the
cheapest, though I don't know if they do hotel pickups. I'm staying the
The Mill.

I'm an experienced diver and don't like having my hand held. 40 minute
dive times tend to upset me too.

Recommendations for the best dives would also be appreciated.

Jason
--
http://www.scuba-addict.co.uk/ for Aussie diving reports including
the Coral Sea, Ningaloo reef, the Solitaries and Byron Bay
Michael Sutton
2003-08-15 17:01:39 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jason
I'm off to Aruba soon and looking around the web, there seems to be a
Mermaid Sport Divers
see below for comments about them (not good)
Post by Jason
Dive Aruba
They are located in the hotel next to the Wyndham. I haven't
heard much from them, but all seems good. I didn't dive with them
but they seemed ok.
Post by Jason
Pelican Watersports
I dove with them. nice operation, located on a pier next to
the Holiday Inn. They provide free pick up and drop off from you
hotel at no extra cost. 2 tank dives were $55 (tanks/weights) and
one tank dives were $35. Very good customer service. I would
definately dive with them again. Both Pelican and Dive Aruba
are located on Palm Beach, just offshore from the Antilla and
Pedernales wreck sites.
Post by Jason
Red Sails
Red Sail is located in the Renasainse/sonesta hotel area. I
heard good things about them. The only negative things I
heard about them was since they were downtown and close
to the cruise boat port, they tended to load up lots
of cruise boat passengers. they are closer to the
better reefs though, which are south of the island.
Post by Jason
Anyone got any personal experience of them? Mermaid seem to be the
cheapest, though I don't know if they do hotel pickups. I'm staying the
The Mill.
I've heard nothing but bad things about Mermaid. Check on the
http://www.aruba.com message boards and you'll hear all kinds of
horror stories about them. From over charging or double charging
your credit card, to sexual assualt by the owner, to inpropper
touching of female divers, to leaving divers in the bottom because
he didn't like how they did something. Since I saw this from
15+ people, then I wouldn't dive with them. Both PADI and NAUI
also have him listed as "no longer affiliated" on their websites.
so he was blacklisted by them for some reason.

For hotel pickups, see Pelican Watersports. The Mill is walking
distance to Dive Aruba. Pelican is walkign distance also,
but not really carrying scuba gear as it's 3/4 mile. Cab fare
in that area is about $5-$6 each way. Cab fare to town from
the hotel district is $10 each way.
Post by Jason
I'm an experienced diver and don't like having my hand held. 40 minute
dive times tend to upset me too.
I think most of the places there tend to limit the dive times.
That was the one negative I noticed. All the dives are led
by a dive master and he seemed to never go past 45 minutes on
any dive. Of course nobody uses air the same, so on some
dives he brought the 'air hogs' back to the anchor line and
took us to dive some more since we had extra air.
Post by Jason
Recommendations for the best dives would also be appreciated.
there are two main diving areas on the island. The West Coast
and the South Coast. All the hotels are located on the West
Coast as are most of the wrecks. The water here is very calm
and pretty clear with water depths of about 60 feet max. The
south coast has better reef systems and are a little deeper.
More in the 40-90' range. there is no diving hardly on
the north coast because hard to get too and the water
is extremely rough and bad currents. There is very little
diving on the east coast for some of the same reasons.
Also these areas have no hotels to accomadate people either.

The wrecks on the West Coast are the Antilla, a 400+ foot freighter
sunk intentionally by it's German crew at the start of WWII
in about 60' of water. The Pedernalis, a freighter torpedoded
and sunk in about 20' of water during WWII. Malmook reef, 60' deep
with a 100' ship sunk at the end of the reef. Arashi Reef 60' deep
with leftover remains of 4 engine plane on the bottom. Most
of the plane gone, only engines and a few pieces left.

While the Pederanalis is very shallow, the snorkel boats feed
the fish there, so the fish come right up to you while you
are diving. This makes it a good dive site to do fish photography
since they hold still in front of you thinking they are going
to get a free snack while you take their picture.

The South coast has various reefs and a few smaller wrecks and
an airplane or two sunk.

Expect water temps 75f to 80f. Most people dove in a shorty
or just a swim suit. I would wear at least a shorty or
a dive skin as some of the ones in the swim suits got a
little cold by the end of the dive or when swimming thru
the cargo holds in the Antillas hold. Visibility varied
by day. It wasn't as great as some other places, but
you still had 30' to 100' of vis, depending on the
dive and the day.

Hope this info helps some. If you have any other questions
just email me.

-mike
Post by Jason
Jason
Doorduijn, Niels
2003-08-16 08:31:40 UTC
Permalink
See comments inserted (I was in Aruba about 2 years ago).

Niels

"Michael Sutton" <***@yahoo.com> wrote:

Red Sails
Post by Michael Sutton
Red Sail is located in the Renasainse/sonesta hotel area. I
heard good things about them. The only negative things I
heard about them was since they were downtown and close
to the cruise boat port, they tended to load up lots
of cruise boat passengers. they are closer to the
better reefs though, which are south of the island.
RedSails is a good outfit, but the boats are build to accomodate plenty of
people. I could easily see it getting very crowded. No complaints from me
though: did a super night dive with them with only two other divers + DM.
Post by Michael Sutton
I've heard nothing but bad things about Mermaid.
Concur. I did one dive with them during my one week stay at the island. I
wanted to do another night dive, but the only dive on the schedule was
shortly before I would take the aircraft (some 12 hours or so and I had been
diving steadily throughout the week). The guy offered to do an extra dive
on Tuesday evening, so I paid an advance, USD 30 or so. Tuesday morning, the
dive gets cancelled for lack of other customers, fair enough (it was
unscheduled), but refunds were against company policy. Why don't I do the
scheduled night dive? (insert obvious reply) Okay, why don't you do an
afternoon dive? (other plans). etc etc Back to the schedule night dive
again, sure I don't want to do that scheduled night dive (repeat obvious
reply + insert me getting annoyed) etc etc (insert excuses, promise to call
at hotel and failing to do so) etc etc. On the last day of the vacation, I
was touring the island with a jeep (now there is something which will take
you a whole 3 hours) and happen to pass by Mermaids headquarters. The lady
there know all about it, just sign this little waiver (releasing them from
just about anything) and voila I got the advance back.

Now don't get me wrong, USD 30 is nothing on the costs of the whole
vacation, but it annoyed the hell out me that he tried a stupid tourist
trick on me. Luckily, internet is a great way to do my bit for a better
Aruba.....
Post by Michael Sutton
I think most of the places there tend to limit the dive times.
That was the one negative I noticed. All the dives are led
by a dive master and he seemed to never go past 45 minutes on
any dive.
This is my recollection as well.
Post by Michael Sutton
Post by Jason
Recommendations for the best dives would also be appreciated.
Concur with earlier comments. A small freighter (Star Garret) was sunk in
2000.

Niels
John Kendall
2003-08-17 10:32:23 UTC
Permalink
Post by Jason
I'm off to Aruba soon and looking around the web, there seems to be a
Red Sails
Can't comment on any of the rest, however I dived with Red Sail every time I
went into aruba (I was working on a cruise ship)

They are very much kitted out for cattle boat style diving, however the
DMs/Instructors were very good, and if you had the time to plan which dives
you wanted to go on could get some very good diving done with them on the
"Quieter" dives. These tend to be the Deeper dives as most of the OW crowd
are not up to them. I think I had one 40min dive with them, but since that
was 30ish M deep and we were on AL80s (I think) I didn't think it was too
bad.

The DM on the boat was very interested in my BP/Wing set-up, as he himself
was thinking of going that route.

All in all I enjoyed the dives I did with them.

HTH
John

Loading...